[Stocker]

Most of what I have heard / read / experienced with Duratrac and BFG All Terrains has been positive, with a few negatives sprinkled in. Between the two, I really like the appearance of the Duratrac but I would buy BFGs. Mostly based on years of owning BFGs, and hearing of problems with Goodyears.

Compared to those two, the Cooper ATP seems like more of a street tire, less of a traction tire. Nothing wrong with it but it's more of an apples to oranges comparison. I would take a good look at Cooper's Discoverer A/T Maxx. In fact, that tire would probably be my top pick for what you are looking for.

Any of those would probably serve you well. Good luck and let us know what you decide.