Thanks for the responses so far.
I did some online quotes after posting this. The quotes are for both my 70 GMC and my 1967 Olds Cutlass with a 468 BBC. I went with agreed value of $50,000 on the GMC and agreed value of $32,000 on the Cutlass. I understand that most likely these quotes will differ when I actually get to talk to someone. All quotes are annual rates. But here are the results so far:
- Hagerty - $1160 with yearly mileage of 1700
- Grundy - $1024 with yearly mileage of 3000
- Heacock - $668 with yearly mileage of 3000
Heacock is $492 cheaper than Hagerty. Quite a bit of savings. Also needs more research to see exactly what I would be getting.
Here's my 67 Cutlass. Which my parents also bought new in 1967.