That's one of the hazards of buying on eBay.. Some of the eBay vendors buy quantities of seconds and blems from the manufacturers and then resell them at a discount. Did you buy directly from American Retro, or from a vendor??
Locar sells a line of steering wheels they call Lecarra.. They don't have any reproduction or OEM type steering wheels, but they do have some "retro" looking wheels, plus a wide range of custom designs.. I bought my truck 6 years ago and a PO had installed a polished aluminum 15" Lecarra wheel.. I don't know how old the wheel is, but it has held up very well over the years, not a mark on it..
Here's a link to the Lecarra site:
https://www.lokar.com/lecarra.html