So here is a picture of the stock reflector (I had previously modified it to fit a deeper bulb), the headlight housing that mounts into the fender and the new LED headlight/halo/turn signal bulb.
While I could further modify the reflector (silver part) to allow the bulb to fit, the bulb is so wide and deep that it won't fit into the housing. Rather than chop most of the housing off, I think I'd like to find a different housing that would allow the wider and deeper bulb to fit properly. Anyone have any ideas?